Witchcraft
Witchcraft is alive and well in Africa. We have often encountered these beliefs among our domestic workers from northern Malawi. In this area, at least 72% of people still believe in magic and will blame any misfortune, poverty, inexplicable illness, and death on witchcraft. This is not only a population gradually evolving out of a tribal, superstitious stage of human evolution, dominated by magical thinking, but they also live in an area marked by extreme tribal conflicts, poverty, land and property disputes, and intergenerational tensions, as young people seek a different way of life by moving to more prosperous regions to try to survive and encounter the intersection of tribal and 1st world aspirations.
Isaac professes to be an evangelist — meaning he has had informal training in preaching Christianity. What this means is unclear, but he does see “God” and “Love” as more powerful than witchcraft — at least this is what he says. He often says that God is not a man and sees everything, which suggests an inner understanding of a powerful god who rewards good and punishes evil — much like a witchdoctor.
Recently, I learned the latest story he told me. His father went to the outhouse, and when he came out, he collapsed to the ground, unable to walk or talk, and looked like a dead man — “he was gone.” The family took him to the hospital. They took blood — everything was normal — no diseases, no fever, no snakebite, nothing at all to explain why he was on the verge of death. The only explanation the family could think of was “witchcraft,” and vengeance needed to be taken on the “witch,” which could be any old woman they decided must be the one who did the sorcery. Many old women are brutally murdered when they are accused of being “witches.” In the Middle Ages, these older women were often herbalists, midwives, and healers, or simply old. The truth is that they are scapegoated to avoid the helplessness, deprivation, shame, fear, and ignorance people are feeling.
However, as the discussion with Isaac continued, he told me his father “must have done something” to be targeted by a witch, often paid by someone to perform dark magic to avenge someone who feels aggrieved. He was very distressed that his father could not tell his children, “Because you do not tell your children the bad things you have done.” He clearly understood that if his father could just talk and confess, he could recover. He was saying that a witchdoctor's dark magic cannot work if someone talks about their shame. Then people do not “die of their shame.” But if you talk, the magic spell cannot work.
I thought about this because this line of thinking follows another experience Isaac had. We lent him some money, and he went home to Malawi, clearly spent it all, and couldn't pay us back when he returned. We heard that he was very, very ill — in the hospital. He lost consciousness, couldn’t walk or talk, and was like a dead man, but the doctors could not find anything wrong with him. As he lay in the hospital bed, the man in the bed on one side died, and then the man on the other side died too. Isaac got a terrible fright in the hospital, jumped up, and ran away. He now believed that he was the victim of witchcraft. He was not well when he returned and tried to argue with us that our figures for what he still owed were wrong.
Charisse and I sat down with him and explained that we wanted to help him, but a relationship must be built on trust. We went back and forth on the figures, and then his wife looked at him sternly and said, “No, your math is wrong; you owe them what they say.” He squirmed, and the internal struggle was immense — and then he broke. He confessed he had spent the money. We were right about the amount he still owed and that he planned to pay it back. He continued to experience severe chest pain and extreme weakness. We took him to the hospital, where elevated cortisol from stress and severe physical exertion was causing severe muscle fatigue. He was in a highly hijacked fight-or-flight state. With rest, hydration, and the relief of telling the truth, he soon returned to normal. Having experienced the relief of confession, he now suspected his father was guilty and that the witchcraft would work on him, the way it had on him.
Poverty, desperation, hopelessness, fear, shame, guilt, and 1st quadrant development conspire to reinforce the magical thinking and superstitions that dominate this stage of human development.
Now we often talk about how “God” loves us even when we do something wrong, and that love is stronger than guilt. So witchcraft cannot work on us if we believe we are good and loving and tell the truth, even if we make mistakes. He tells me repeatedly that he is very afraid of “disappointing me.” I tell him over and over that even if he makes a mistake, I will not be disappointed because I know who he really is.
It feels like an honor to speak into this stage of development; it is like I am reaching back into the Middle Ages in Europe with a message of love for the immense suffering of those times.
And then I remember that we still do this to ourselves – not in such dramatic ways, but nonetheless, we damn ourselves to hells of shame with the spells and curses of judgment and self-hatred; we do not want to talk about the mistakes we make; we live in silence, dying of shame, and do not see that we are the witches casting the spell of death over us. We are terrified of other people finding out, of seeing the dark within us, and so our immune systems are compromised and our health suffers too. The avenger, the witch, and the victim are archetypes we still haven't fully brought into the light of our own truth and love; instead, we project these dark energies onto other people, blame them for our inner state, and then attack them for what we do to ourselves.
Exercise:- What beliefs do you firmly believe in as true, and how do they impact your internal and external life? Did you learn these beliefs before age five, when you still lived in a magical and superstitious realm of consciousness?
- How do you blame others for your own feelings?
- How do you internally deny the truth of what you have done, or not done, with rationalizations, justifications, excuses, and denial?
- How do you search out wrongdoing even when there isn’t any, obsessing and ruminating about what is wrong with you?
- How do your own thoughts create shame, guilt, and fear?
- How do you seek vengeance on yourself and others?
- Can you take responsibility when you make a mistake without defense?
- Can you relate your thoughts, feelings, needs, and actions to the truth, accept your human condition, and embrace it all with love?
- Talk about experiences in your life when you thought you could have died of shame.
Postscript: Isaac's father died within the week. Before he died, he vomited white glass beads. He had clearly seen the Sangoma for a remedy against the curse of the “witch.” Isaac believes he made a bargain many years ago with the Sangoma, who would heal him of infertility but would require three deaths in return. Isaac believes he and his son were part of that original bargain, which explains his sickness a few months ago. He also believes God saved him. Can you see how this same story mirrors Abraham being asked to sacrifice his firstborn child in the mythology of the primitive Jewish tribal nation of the Old Testament? Isaac is a man trapped between stages and states. He moves from 1st Quadrant to 2nd Quadrant fundamentalism, each stage bringing its own suffering and challenges.
In terms of Ken Wilber’s levels of development, he is between the magenta and amber stages.
Use this simplified outline to assess the ways in which you move between different stages in your own thinking, moment by moment. What is the center of gravity for your own development? Are you aware when younger parts of yourself assert their beliefs and thoughts? Remember, every stage is within you. What is true at one stage is not true at other stages, which creates inner tension and conflict that you must resolve through awareness and deep understanding.